You know me too well, anon….
Hmmm. If I was recasting, I’d probably make it an animated film series, so we wouldn’t have any awful child acting, and the effects would hold up a lot better.
For Harry? Maybe Darren Criss. He gets Harry’s sass really well. We’d have to make sure he got some vocal coaching for a British accent, though.
For Hermione? I’m not sure. Maybe Jodie Whittaker? Or maybe
Noma Dumezweni (who played Hermione in The Play That Shall Not Be Named)? But I would have to insist that the actor re-read all the book series before they started work on their interpretation; we don’t want another ‘Hermione was a perfect goddess who could do no wrong’ situation.
Obviously, Rupert would be brought back as Ron. As much as I love Joey’s take on the character, Rupert is the definitive Ron for me.
As for anyone-else?
Maybe Tom Hiddlestone as Percy? I like what the film actor did with the role, but it would be interesting to see Hiddlestone’s take on it.
Steven Fry as Ludo Bagman.
Thanks for the ask, anon!