Hi!! I really like your posts and though I’m primarily a dramione shipper, I also understand and like romione a lot. However you seem to be shaming (?) people who like Hermione. Why so?

headcanonsandmore:

Hello- thank you! I’m glad that my posts are enjoyable to people who don’t necessarily ship the same pairings i do. 🙂 

Oh, have I? I apologise if it seems that way. That wasn’t my intention. I like Hermione as a character. She’s intelligent, got a good heart, and is one half of my OTP (Romione), so I can’t really say I dislike her as a character. 

What I do dislike, however, is the way that some (but none all) people in the fandom tend to ignore her more negative personality traits and bad decisions. I feel it’s something of a disservice to the character to idealise her. Maybe the films had an impact on the way some in the fandom view her, but I might just be clutching at straws there. 

I’m not trying to shame people who like her. I’m just trying to discuss Hermione’s more negative traits and actions. I apologise if that’s coming across as shaming people who like the character. I’ll try and do better in the future.

Thanks for the message, anon! 🙂 

Thanks @hillyminne!

Is there anything you don’t like about Ron? Like I find my number one favourite characters ever annoying sometimes lol xx

That’s a very good
question! Yes, there are a few things that I don’t like about Ron. Obviously,
the character isn’t perfect, and I wouldn’t want him to be.

1-   
Ron’s lack of
self-belief

This is one of
the things that maddens me everytime I read the HP series. From the very first
time we meet him, Ron’s inability to believe in his own abilities stands out
like a sore thumb. In his very first meeting with Harry, Ron says that he’s
“got a lot to live up”. All of his older brothers have some distinguishing
characteristic that makes them stand out from the crowd. Bill was head-boy and
went on to be a curse-breaker, Charlie was brilliant at Quidditch and works
with dragons, Percy was very intelligent and a prefect, whilst Fred and George
were really funny and still got high marks.

By contrast, Ron
doesn’t have a lot of room to make his own name. He even points out that ‘Everyone expects me to do as well as the
others, but if I do, it’s no big deal, because they did it first
’. And
thus, Ron’s lack of confidence in his own abilities is laid out; what’s the
point in trying if you’ll never stand out even when you do succeed?  

Throughout the
series, Ron never performs especially well academic-wise. Of course, this could
be simply down to the fact that he was the only one of his siblings who had to
start Hogwarts with a second-hand wand (even Ginny got her own, whilst Ron had
to use his now-broken hand-me-down for the whole of his second year), but I
think it has something to do with his own lack of self-belief.

Out of the trio,
he gets the lowest marks of his OWLs (although still getting better marks than
Fred and George, I might add), and has a habit of being largely ignored by
teachers unless he’s doing something wrong (heck, Slughorn ignores Ron
throughout most of sixth year because he doesn’t seem him as ‘special’ like
Harry and Hermione).

Ron’s
insecurities are the main driving force behind his character arc, but it still
pains me to see Ron never believing in himself or his own abilities.

 And the worse
thing is- Ron is actually RIDICULOUSLY good at magic.

He is somehow
able to cast non-verbal spells (something
sixth-year students struggle with) at the age of twelve, through a broken
second-hand wand that didn’t even choose him as its owner.

He also breaks
Gamp’s Law of Elemental Transfiguration while he does it (creating slugs-
technically a form of food- out of nothing).

Not only that,
but he also has a bizarre talent for predicting future events;

  • He correctly predicted
    that Tom Riddle had murdered Myrtle
  • That Harry would
    be happy about feeling sad in third year
  • That Harry would
    be stabbed in the back by someone he thought a friend (the fake Moody)

And
he’s really good at emotional magic;

  • Was the first of
    the trio to realise that the Horcrux locket was sort-of alive
  • Correctly guessed
    that Voldemort’s name had the taboo on it
  • Was able to work
    out how the Deluminator worked, and used it to get back to Harry and Hermione

Ron
was brilliant as a wizard, but, thanks to his own lack of self-belief and
constantly getting ignored in favour of those around him, his talents were
never really recognised.

2-   
Ron’s apparent immaturity

Up until GOF,
Ron was the most emotionally-mature member of the golden trio. He was able to
keep a cool head in tense situations, and was able to read his friends’
emotions far better than anyone ever gave him credit for.

However, in GOF,
Ron’s emotional maturity (as well as his intelligence) takes a sudden
nose-dive. Now, I’m not saying that this was caused by JK Rowling’s meetings
with Steve Kloves when developing the film series in between POA and GOF, but it’s
a possibility that Kloves’ love (read ‘idealisation’) of Hermione rubbed off on
Rowling, and she decided to write Ron as emotionally-insensitive (especially
when it came to girls) and more immature than his two friends.

The difference
between the Ron of the first three books, and the Ron of the later four books
is quite a large one. Pre-GOF Ron was occasionally insensitive but pretty
bang-on when it came to people’s emotions. Post-GOF Ron had a dramatic cut to
his maturity and overall intelligence. It’s as if JK Rowling assumed that boys
undergoing puberty must have their emotional maturity and intelligence
drastically reduced just because of their hormones.

And, while that
may be true to a certain extent, it’s the fact that even Ron’s mature moments
in the later books is still framed as
‘immature’ that annoys me. Even when Ron is actually acting maturely for his
age (like not talking to Hermione after she attacks him with a flock of
ravenous birds- a pretty sensible response to it, I would say), Rowling frames
it as immature so as to make Hermione seem more sympathetic. It drives me up
the wall.

3-   
What happened
with Lavender.

Nothing really
to say here. I think he should have dated Luna for a bit instead. Lavender’s
personality in HBP seems really off compared to how she was written before. Luna
would have been a better fit for Ron, in my opinion. They would have made a
cute couple, and it would have showed Hermione that she had to show Ron affection
if she wanted him romantically. With Lavender, it was framed as ‘why is Ron dating such an irritating girl?
He should be dating Hermione instead
’. What would have been better for
character-growth (especially for Hermione) would be framing Ron dating someone
as ‘Ron responds positively when girls
show obvious affection for him. Maybe Hermione should take this on-board
’.  

Ron isn’t perfect, but that’s why I like him. He’s
imperfectly perfect, and I wouldn’t have him any other way. The flaws are what
make him three-dimensional.

image

(Thanks for the ask, anon!)

For the Hogwarts ask, 3, 9, and 26 please

3: Butterbeer, fire whisky, or pumpkin juice? Pumpkin juice. Butterbeer is apparently really sugary (not my thing), I don’t drink alcohol so Fire-Whisky is out, and I quite like fruit-juices. Pumpkin juice it is. 

9: Notp? Harmony (Harry x Hermione). I always saw them as siblings. Also, a small minority of people who ship them tend to like bashing Ron (leave my ginger baby alone!). No disrespect to those who ship them, but it’s not my cup of tea. 

26: Lowkey ships? Deamus (I’m pretty sure everyone ships these two), Larvati (these two deserve some happiness after all they went through), and Perciver (they were room-mates for seven years, and I like their dynamic). 

Thanks for the asks, @accioqueer

1, 7, 32, 45 for the HP asks :)

1. Hogwarts House?  Hufflepuff! Up the badgers! Inter-house unity for the win!

7: Top five ships? Already did this, but…

  1. Romione (my OTP)
  2. Lunarry
  3. Linny
  4. Linuarry (Luna x Harry x Ginny) 
  5. Rarry (in an AU setting, and/or having simultaneously with Romione)

32: Favorite friendship? Harry and Ron. My BROTP.

45: Favorite minor character? Hmm. Probably Susan Bones. She was smart, kind and a good example of Hufflepuff house. 

Thanks for the asks, @salovie

#9 Notp?

Harry x Hermione. I always considered them to be siblings, and I’ve never quite understood why people think that they could have worked as a couple, since their personalities don’t react well together. 

Don’t get me wrong, when I first read PS/SS, I thought the bit where Hermione hugged Harry was very cute. But it was in an innocent, ‘11-year-old boy gets embarrassed because his female friend hugged him’ kind-of-way. Nothing especially romantic. 

The series is from Harry’s perspective. If he had ever fancied Hermione, we probably would have heard about it. 

I don’t have any massive problems with the ship itself (they have a canonical caring, close relationship), but a small minority of those who ship it have a habit of bashing Ron Weasley, and dismissing Hermione’s feelings for Ron as ‘he could never make her happy’.  Which I think is just being rude about the characters. This small minority remind me of people who assume that it’s impossible for opposite-gender friendships to exist without romance getting involved. 

I think that the HP film series had a serious impact on how many in the fandom viewed Harry and Hermione’s relationship (as well as Ron and Hermione’s). The films based their friendship around the idea that the trio are in the Hollywood ‘hero, heroine, sidekick’ mould, rather than ‘Harry, and his two friends who happened to fall in love’. 

No disrespect to those who ship it, but it’s not my cup of tea. 

1,7,13,32 from HP themed asks

1- Patronus? No idea. I’m not on Pottermore. Probably a dog or a hedgehog. 

7- Top five ships? 

  1. Romione (Ron and Hermione)- my OTP. 
  2. Lunarry (Luna and Harry). I like Hinny, but I honestly think this would have made more sense character-wise. 
  3. Linny. They’re so sweet, and balance each other out so well. 
  4. Linuarry (Poly ship throuple with Harry, Luna and Ginny all dating each other). I honestly feel this is the best outcome, since they all balance each other out brilliantly.
  5. Rarry (as an AU, or happening in the post-war years in a poly ship with Romione, as in Harry and Hermione both being in love with Ron). 

13- Character you most identify with? Probably a mixture of Ron (insecurities, self-doubts and loyalty), Hermione (book-worm tendencies) and Neville (used to get bullied and had low self-esteem). 

32- Favorite friendship? Probably Harry and Ron. I suppose I could also say the golden trio, but Harry and Hermione just don’t have the same connection that Harry and Ron have. Harry and Ron are platonic (almost romantic) soul-mates in so many ways, and care for each other so much. My BROTP, if you will. 

Thanks for the ask, @idratherstayhufflepuff

About the ‘I’m highly logical’ quote, I remember reading that Emma wrote a lot of her own lines and that they would ask her to fill in some blanks that they couldn’t think of dialogue for her. I wonder if that quote is from her or Kloves? Or if she said that about Hermione and Kloves just used it?

That would explain a lot…

Since Emma Watson has repeatedly proved that her understanding of Hermione is based on the Steve-Kloves version rather than the Rowling version (i.e; Hermione not being a well-rounded character with human flaws), this would not surprise me in the slightest. 

Because it certainly doesn’t reflect the book character at all, especially not during the first three books (funnily enough, the three books written before the film series began. Coincidence? I think not…)

Emma Watson does very much toe the Rowling-Kloves line of ‘Hermione is a bad-ass warrior-queen who can do no wrong’, and, while she has displayed a love for the Romione pairing, she does often tailor her opinions depending on the tone of interviews (especially when it comes to discussing Ron’s character). 

She’s referred to Hermione as (and I’m paraphrasing at best) ‘making the boys tag along with her on adventures’ and that ‘Ron couldn’t really make Hermione happy’, which shows that she probably hasn’t read in the books in a while, and likely missed the entire point of both the golden trio (they all brought something unique to the table) and the Romione relationship (Hermione and Ron fell in love; Hermione didn’t ‘settle for Ron’). 

And, if that quote is from Kloves (either if he came up with or decided to use a quote from Emma), that would make even more sense. Since the screen-writer seemed to ignore the parts of Hermione’s character that were in any way negative or gave her a three-dimensional personality. 

I apologise for going on a bit of a rant here, but I really do get sick of people (including Kloves, Rowling and, to a lesser extent, Emma Watson) making Hermione out to be some kind of perfect person, because it’s an insult to the character. Hermione wasn’t perfect, and she would likely be very angry that so many people treat her as such. 

I’m thinking about answering questions as Harry Potter characters. First up is the golden trio, in a series I’m calling “ask harry ron and hermione” (check the tag for one I’ve done already). 

Any questions?